MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
More tagged , ,

What do you think of Chrysler's turnaround chances?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 8 short comments
Total of 434 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

33.2%
No chance. The company can never achieve the profits being projected.
144 votes
44%
Good chance. The marriage with Fiat is likely to achieve strong results.
191 votes
22.8%
Not sure, too early to tell.
99 votes
Display Comments:
Not sure, too early to tell.

If Americans can act in our own interest, and forget our inferiority complex, then Chrysler will be with us for a good long time to come.

{"commentId":10526927,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"spammyhole"}
     - 2:43 pm EST on Fri Nov 6, 2009

    Chrylser is suing its customers! Why buy their cars?

    {"commentId":10539347,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jack-mi"}
       - Jack-mi
       - 8:56 am EST on Sat Nov 7, 2009
      Not sure, too early to tell.

      If it Chrysler becomes profitable, it'll be because of the Italians. American executives are worthless.

      {"commentId":10582206,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"indigohalo"}
      • 1 vote
       - 5:49 pm EST on Mon Nov 9, 2009
      Good chance. The marriage with Fiat is likely to achieve strong results.

      Contrary to some misguided & negative press coverage, Chrysler's mix is excellent, including the 300-series, Dodge trucks and the Jeep line

      {"commentId":10586115,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jreostude"}
         - 9:41 pm EST on Mon Nov 9, 2009
        No chance. The company can never achieve the profits being projected.

        Too much bad product for too many years. Some (few) models may still keep Chrysler logo, but the rest will either be spun off or sold.

        {"commentId":10595388,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"csmallis"}
        • 1 vote
         - 12:11 pm EST on Tue Nov 10, 2009
        No chance. The company can never achieve the profits being projected.

        I hope Chrysler goes down in flames. This way my dealership will still be open and the one that stole our franchise will go down with them.

        {"commentId":10662850,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"skapades"}
           - 1:50 pm EST on Fri Nov 13, 2009
          No chance. The company can never achieve the profits being projected.

          I wouldn't say no chance. But i wouldn't bet on them. I bet GM gets cut in half....again. Ford's doing ok...

          {"commentId":10730805,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"sean-951"}
             - 3:59 pm EST on Tue Nov 17, 2009
            No chance. The company can never achieve the profits being projected.

            Was always junk. Fix it again Tony (FIAT) won't save it.

            {"commentId":11531133,"threadId":"718198","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"PKOtoole"}
            • 1 vote
             - 11:58 am EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
            advertisement

            Newsvine Discussion with 23 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

            {"commentId":10509085,"authorDomain":"rt5303"}

            The "rebirth" of Chrysler is dependent upon the success of Fiat and Alfa Romeo in the US market and a reduction in current Chrysler models. Chrysler is the only automotive company planning on increasing the number of brands that it sells in the US. Isn't this the same mistake that GM made years ago?

            Let's think about this for about a New York minute. GM will now focus on four brands in the US. Toyota, Honda, Nissan each have two. Chrysler sales were off 30% from a year ago and a year ago the credit markets were frozen. Chrysler management is planning to increase the number of brands it sells????

            The Fiat 500, coming to a dealership near you, will be made in Mexico. Other Fiat products and Alfa Romeo's will be made in "North America".

            Government Motors you've done it again. Our neighbors to the South and probably to the North appreciate our financial contribution to their economies since it appears that they will benefit from any jobs that are created by the Fiat/Chrysler merger.

            Of course, we did get something out of the deal. We got to pick up the check.

            God Bless America.

            {"commentId":10509085,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"rt5303"}
            • 1 vote
            Reply#1 - Thu Nov 5, 2009 7:52 PM EST
            {"commentId":10523018,"authorDomain":"zack-1451944"}

            First off Richard 23, unlike GM, the gov't only owns 8% of Chrysler. Secondly, only the 500 will be built in Mexico. As for "North American" production, the Candian gov't also contributed to the bailout loans. Chrysler has only 2 plants in Canada, the minivan plant and the Charger/300/Challenger plant. To give you an idea of what that means to the US, the minivan plant in Windsor, Ontario just across the river from Detroit, has parts manufatured all over the US mid-west by parts manufatcures and Chrysler itself and are brought to Canada to assemble the van. More of the components come from the US than Canada for that vehicle, so it does dramatically help the US economy. The same holds true for the 300 plant just out side of Toronto. One only needs to look at the 2 WAY traffic at the Ambassador Bridge in Detroit/Windsor to see how the relationship between our 2 countries benefit each other. As far as Chrysler adding a brand, all they are doing is separating the trucks out of Dodge, which is you look at how they want to position Dodge and Ram in the presentation, you can understand why this is being done.

            {"commentId":10523018,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"zack-1451944"}
            • 1 vote
            #1.1 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 12:27 PM EST
            {"commentId":10527012,"authorDomain":"spammyhole"}

            Thank you, Zack, for bringing some facts and truth to this discussion, to counter the irrational hatred of the government that seems to dominate the discourse most places. It is in all Americans' interest to hope and work for the survival of Chrysler, as your post clearly illustrates.

            {"commentId":10527012,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"spammyhole"}
              #1.2 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 2:46 PM EST
              {"commentId":10531253,"authorDomain":"pmoore"}

              Will the Fiat 500 carry the Fiat name or the Chrysler name?  It's hard to imagine the name Fiat doing well if it's not made as a Chrysler.  Who is going to work on a Fiat if you don't live in a bigger city in the U.S.?

              {"commentId":10531253,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"pmoore"}
                #1.3 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 5:27 PM EST
                {"commentId":10539418,"authorDomain":"jack-mi"}

                Tens of thousands of good Chrysler customers were not refinanced by Chrysler at lease end during the credit crunch. Chrysler forced them to turn in leased vehicles they wanted to buy. These-often very good repeat customers-were hit with turn-in fees (over mileage, damages, etc). Chrysler is now filing tens of thousands of LAWSUITS against these former loyal customers to collect this money! I bought 4 Chryslers since 2001. I made all the payments on time. Now Chrysler is suing me-and not paying back their government loans. Sound right to you? Think I'll buy another Chrysler?

                {"commentId":10539418,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jack-mi"}
                • 1 vote
                #1.4 - Sat Nov 7, 2009 9:03 AM EST
                Reply
                {"commentId":10516449,"authorDomain":"desserx"}

                I sure hope this works out. We need American vehicles!!!

                {"commentId":10516449,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"desserx"}
                • 1 vote
                Reply#2 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 8:22 AM EST
                {"commentId":10527037,"authorDomain":"spammyhole"}

                Heartily seconded. That's a point too many Americans seem to have rationalized away many years ago.

                {"commentId":10527037,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"spammyhole"}
                  #2.1 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 2:47 PM EST
                  {"commentId":11182014,"authorDomain":"network-gal"}

                  I hope also! After driving a Porsche for 26 years (which I still believe is a Superior car) I bought a 2004 Sebring convertible and have been very pleased with my "first automatic". I did buy the extended warranty which I have hardly used but get great service at the dealer. No tune up in 2 years and it purrs. Just drove it 12 hours from Jacksonville to Kentucky on 2 tanks of gas and had ABSOLUTLY no problem. Keep up the good work Chrysler!!!!

                  {"commentId":11182014,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"network-gal"}
                    #2.2 - Sun Dec 13, 2009 11:58 AM EST
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":10517051,"authorDomain":"argueta930"}

                    I have said this before, but I think that this turnaround plan will take too long. Eventually, they may find some success with the new cars that they introduce over the next few years, but they will remain two steps behind everyone else. Ford, Toyota, Mazda, and even Volkswagen are introducing new cars now. In three years, these companies will have sold tens of thousands of their new cars while Fiat and Chrysler are still designing and testing their cars. Some folks have told me that Chrysler will be 'refreshing' and 'improving' their current models for the time being. That's certainly a step in the right direction, but a 'refreshed' Dodge Avenger may not appeal to consumers becuase they still will think about the severe lack of quality with which Chrysler cars are associated now.

                    I still believe that the best bet is for Chrysler and Fiat to drastically reduce the number of models that they offer, and concentrate on making those models shine. Keep the Jeep Wrangler and Cherokee. Keep the Dodge Charger, Caravan, and Challenger. Keep the Ram pickups. Toss out the compact and mid-size cars and replace them with Fiat models that wear Dodge or Chrysler badges.

                    {"commentId":10517051,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"argueta930"}
                      Reply#3 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 8:55 AM EST
                      {"commentId":10522532,"authorDomain":"gpennell"}

                      How is FIAT," fix it again Tony", going to improve Chrysler reliability? I would like a Fiat 500 diesel, I will take that chance.

                      {"commentId":10522532,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"gpennell"}
                        Reply#4 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 12:09 PM EST
                        {"commentId":10527054,"authorDomain":"spammyhole"}

                        How old is your information? Fiat's current lineup is exceedingly well-received. Or are you just perpetuating an outdated stereotype?

                        {"commentId":10527054,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"spammyhole"}
                          #4.1 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 2:48 PM EST
                          Reply
                          {"commentId":10527157,"authorDomain":"spammyhole"}

                          FTA:

                          American taxpayers should hope the plan works.

                          That is the key to the whole thing. Way too many (purported) Americans are terrified that we will succeed, and start making more and more world-class cars, and become economically healthy, prosperous and successful. Why this desperate fear of success? Why, because it might just prove that a black man with a (D) after his name presided over a successful plan. If we really hope Chrysler will succeed, then we will give its products a chance. I firmly believe if we do that, then Chrysler will succeed. But I am scared as hell that these so-called Americans will keep on exporting their paychecks without a moment's consideration of American brands, if for no other reason than just to claim that President Obama failed.

                          It will be interesting to see how many Americans are truly on the side of America.

                          {"commentId":10527157,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"spammyhole"}
                            Reply#5 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 2:52 PM EST
                            {"commentId":10529307,"authorDomain":"jim-hoover"}

                            Ladies and Gentlemen, the whole thing about the turnaround hinges on 1) ECONOMY, 2) how well Fiat can overcome its let's say not so sterling image of being a cheap import not worth 2 cents, and lastly how well the AMERICAN consumer is going to receive the cars that they are going to put out especially those that do not have good styling. Quality has got to improve by 300% on the current models, fuel efficeny has got to increase in all lines to new minimium standards that go in to effect with in the next couple of years, and lets face it, gas and diesel are not getting any cheaper. I have serious doubts about the plan, but I wish Fiat the best of luck. If the US economy does not improve and drastically, then they have slim to no chance of making it. Of course this is just MHO

                            {"commentId":10529307,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jim-hoover"}
                              Reply#6 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 4:08 PM EST
                              {"commentId":10530856,"authorDomain":"jack-mi"}

                              No chance. Chrysler is right now suing thousands who could not re-finance leases during the credit crunch! None of these people will ever be customers again! Neither will their family or friends! Nice move-sue your customers- Brilliant!

                              {"commentId":10530856,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jack-mi"}
                              • 1 vote
                              Reply#7 - Fri Nov 6, 2009 5:09 PM EST
                              {"commentId":10539084,"authorDomain":"chrysler"}

                              As a former direct hire employee of Chrysler, having worked in the field for ten years and in Michigan for ten years, I would be surprised if they make it five years. They have been telling us that they get it on the quality thing for twenty years, but the quality peaked in 1998 and has been on a steady decline. The fact that they are simply giving loser models quick sheet metal and interior up grades shows how out of touch with reality they really are. If the economy does a sudden and dramatic rebound, they will make it in spite of poor quality and lack luster marketing.

                              {"commentId":10539084,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"chrysler"}
                                Reply#8 - Sat Nov 7, 2009 8:28 AM EST
                                {"commentId":10539331,"authorDomain":"jack-mi"}

                                Tens of thousands of good Chrysler customers were not refinanced by Chrysler at lease end during the credit crunch. Chrysler forced them to turn in leased vehicles they wanted to buy. These-often very good repeat customers-were hit with turn-in fees (over mileage, damages, etc). Chrysler is now filing tens of thousands of LAWSUITS against these former loyal customers to collect this money! I bought 4 Chryslers since 2001. I made all the payments on time. Now Chrysler is suing me-and not paying back their government loans. Sound right to you? Think I'll buy another Chrysler?

                                {"commentId":10539331,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jack-mi"}
                                  Reply#9 - Sat Nov 7, 2009 8:54 AM EST
                                  {"commentId":10606952,"authorDomain":"blacksea7"}

                                  I searched the web to see if there's any validity to your comment. I can't find it... Furthermore, your comment makes no practical sense. I'll watch and see where this goes.. most likely, no where.

                                  {"commentId":10606952,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"blacksea7"}
                                    #9.1 - Tue Nov 10, 2009 8:17 PM EST
                                    Reply
                                    {"commentId":10568160,"authorDomain":"buonafortunapiccolino"}

                                    It ain't gonna be easy but I think this guy has a smart plan. However changing the mentality of an american manufacturer such as Chrysler to the idea of them making small italian cars in America will be extremely difficult. I still think they can pull it off only if QUALITY is put to the fore. To Jim, rest assure that Fiat and Alfas ALL have great styling. Fiat has been the only growing company in the competitive and recesion ridden european market for the past two years, this tells you that what they sell is worth buying. To Jack-mi, I sympathise with you man, what they did is unexcusable but give this american brand a chance under these new owners. I really hope we americans can see the positives in this merger by taking advantage of the new technologies being offered while helping us forget an old stereotype about Fiats.

                                    {"commentId":10568160,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"buonafortunapiccolino"}
                                      Reply#10 - Sun Nov 8, 2009 11:51 PM EST
                                      {"commentId":10606669,"authorDomain":"blacksea7"}

                                      This will work. How cant' it? American CEO's suck! Keep the Nardelli's and Eaton's out of it and Chrysler will do well... no matter how you cut it, the three headed dog had no chance after D.B was done milking Chrysler... thank you Eaton.. you go down in the annals of history as a prime jackass! Nardelli, well, what can I say... excreted fecies!

                                      {"commentId":10606669,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"blacksea7"}
                                      • 1 vote
                                      Reply#11 - Tue Nov 10, 2009 8:03 PM EST
                                      {"commentId":10663199,"authorDomain":"skapades"}

                                      As an employee of a former Chrysler dealer, our franchise was taken in June, which we're still trying to figure out because we were number 1 in the Northeast and in the top 12% nationwide. Not to mention that our franchise was given to another dealer. I hope they crash and burn so my dealership will continue with a different franchise and the competitor will go down with them. Even though I work for a certain dealership, I'm a Ford person at heart!...You know that AMERICAN Manufacturer that didn't file for bankruptcy!

                                      {"commentId":10663199,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"skapades"}
                                        Reply#12 - Fri Nov 13, 2009 2:02 PM EST
                                        {"commentId":11112175,"authorDomain":"magnumrt5"}

                                        Ever notice that the one's that complain about Chrysler (GM/Ford) are the most unpatriotic vermin that inhabit this once proud land. They wouldn't buy ANY American made product if it was given away and then take good American money while they're employed at some American company. Boycott those companies people. Chrysler will make it, and will come back with some outstanding products.

                                        Notice how Communist Reports Magazine slams American vehicles, and yet heaps praise on Toyota et al, even though Toyota has frame problems, sticking pedals that are killing people, truck engine failures, car transmission failures? Yet another outfit that hates American products. What a crock.

                                        {"commentId":11112175,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"magnumrt5"}
                                          Reply#13 - Wed Dec 9, 2009 12:01 PM EST
                                          {"commentId":11181712,"authorDomain":"jreostude"}

                                          As owner of new Chrysler products (as well as other makes - we have always owned multiple vehicles at one time... for work and family) for over 22 years, I have never been disappointed with any of our MOPAR purchases. From an '87 Dodge Caravan and a '92 Chrysler Town & Country to a '95 Concorde, a '99 300M, two PT Cruisers (all high-quality, trouble-free, high-mileage vehicles - some with well over 170,000 miles on them at trade) to our latest 2009 300C sedan (a wonderful, award winning and excellent car... so much so, Ford did almost a direct lift of it for its new Taurus SHO), I have been completely satisfied with every Chrysler product we have owned. As with other American manufacturers, Chrysler had competitive difficulties internationally because of its long-term hourly labor rate contracts and employee benefit costs. Add to this Daimler-Benzes' use of Chrysler Corporation as a "subsidiary cash cow", a time when Mercedes Benz vehicles' reputation for poor quality & poor reliability reached all-time highs - 1998 through 2005, and Chrysler's new product development dollars were diverted to Stuttgart instead of staying in Detroit... & you get a sense of part of the big picture. Let's hope that the "new" relationship with FIAT will be equally advantageous to both FIAT and Chrysler and not lopsided as was in the case with Mercedes-Benz!

                                          {"commentId":11181712,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"jreostude"}
                                            Reply#14 - Sun Dec 13, 2009 11:35 AM EST
                                            {"commentId":11182191,"authorDomain":"network-gal"}

                                            What ever happened to the "buy American" mantra? I can remember when you used to show your patriotism by buying American. I had wished the cash for clunkers program had been limited to American cars. Were we too afraid of the world opinion and perceived protectionism?

                                            {"commentId":11182191,"threadId":"717847","contentId":"3465501","authorDomain":"network-gal"}
                                              Reply#15 - Sun Dec 13, 2009 12:09 PM EST
                                              {"canLink":false,"threadId":"717847","isPrivate":false}
                                              Leave a Comment:
                                              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.