MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement

How much do you plan to spend this year on holiday gifts?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 45 short comments
Total of 2,577 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

23.3%
$0 to $100
601 votes
30.1%
$100 to $300
775 votes
21.3%
$300 to $500
549 votes
10.1%
$500 to $700
261 votes
15.2%
More than $700
391 votes
Display Comments:
$0 to $100

Time gets bolder, children get older, and I'm gettin' older, too....

{"commentId":10439414,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"pattigirl10"}
  • 2 votes
 - 11:28 pm EST on Mon Nov 2, 2009
$100 to $300

Used to buy $50 gift for brother and a $50 gift for his wife but now i am getting them ONE $50 "couple" gift maybe a restuarant gift card.

{"commentId":10441756,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"henryleslie"}
  • 6 votes
 - 7:48 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
More than $700

I spend the same every year...but look closely for bargins.

{"commentId":10442605,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"susweir"}
     - 8:58 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
    $300 to $500

    Less than usual...And probably more than I can afford....

    {"commentId":10443348,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"colomtnwoman"}
    • 1 vote
     - 9:40 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
    $0 to $100

    The cost of everything just goes up and up and up...Hours at work are cut..It's time to break from the "money Orgy"!!!!

    {"commentId":10443356,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"rick-2010"}
    • 4 votes
     - 9:40 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
    $0 to $100

    With so much "Made in China" there isn't must choice out there for quality, lead/PVC/phthalates/BPA-free toys.

    {"commentId":10443727,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"pacificnwmom"}
    • 1 vote
     - 9:58 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
    $300 to $500

    I give cash to my four adult kids and buy a nice gift for my parents. Nothing for sibling gifts, decorations or a big meal this year.

    {"commentId":10444473,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"tishrogge"}
       - 10:33 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
      $0 to $100

      Same as always - next to nothing. We've crossed commercial Christmas off our list years ago. We buy "one" something nice for the house.

      {"commentId":10444573,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"cece-borjeson"}
      • 2 votes
       - 10:37 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
      $0 to $100

      We are making our own gifts this year. Mostly food-stuffs like mixed nuts, caramel corn, etc. I think people are more willing to go without

      {"commentId":10445071,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"jujubug00"}
      • 1 vote
       - 11:03 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
      $300 to $500

      We just do one $50 gift these days for each person. Luckily, my family is small, or that would be a smaller number.

      {"commentId":10445218,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"tarchannon"}
         - Tarc
         - 11:11 am EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
        $300 to $500

        Will probably only spend $25/person on gifts, and will make sure it's something they can actually use/need.

        {"commentId":10446395,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"ky-woman"}
        • 2 votes
         - 12:08 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
        $0 to $100

        Maybe a 20.00 gift exchange at work. Otherwise, plan to donate what I can to those truly in need of food and shelter.

        {"commentId":10446610,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lspagnola2007"}
           - 12:20 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
          $0 to $100

          Going to be a family year.

          {"commentId":10446893,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"jerry-hudges"}
          • 2 votes
           - 12:32 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
          $100 to $300

          Lost my job this year and I'll not be spending $1,000+ on Amazon.com as I did last year.

          {"commentId":10447515,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"george-sica"}
             - 12:56 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
            $300 to $500

            Gifts for our son only this year due to corporate greed. Corporate America quick buck metality vs long term growth got us to this point!

            {"commentId":10447598,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"new-reality"}
               - 1:00 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
              $100 to $300

              Only buying presents for the kid under 12, everyone else gets a hug.

              {"commentId":10447672,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"theprairieprankster"}
              • 3 votes
               - 1:02 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
              $100 to $300

              Gonna keep gifts down, but will entertain and eat like MAD!

              {"commentId":10448806,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lietome"}
              • 2 votes
               - LieToMe
               - 1:44 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
              $0 to $100

              We stopped the Commercial Christmas Spend A Thons nearly 10 years ago. Spending was never the reason for the season

              {"commentId":10449287,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"karensbritton"}
              • 3 votes
               - 2:02 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
              $300 to $500

              If you have kids you are going to spend. My wife and I will control our spending on each other.

              {"commentId":10449950,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"brian-porter-1"}
                 - 2:27 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                $300 to $500

                I'm 65 years old and this is the worst economy I have seen

                {"commentId":10451073,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"ken-1449643"}
                   - 3:11 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                  More than $700

                  Instead of giving more than one gift to each person, I plan on spending a little more and giving just one nice gift.

                  {"commentId":10451119,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lammie"}
                     - chop007
                     - 3:12 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                    More than $700

                    With a family of 4, incl. 2 little kids $200 a person is easy to spend.

                    {"commentId":10451256,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"frank-daddy"}
                    • 1 vote
                     - 3:18 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                    $100 to $300

                    Less than usual. We used to fill the room with multiple presents for everyone. It was obscene. We should have been saving for retirement

                    {"commentId":10451482,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"beth-l-mcc"}
                    • 5 votes
                     - 3:26 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                    $500 to $700

                    $300 to $500, but that includes refurbishing needed items (like clothing) for my son who is at college. Mostly practical gifts this year!

                    {"commentId":10451645,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"readermystery43"}
                    • 1 vote
                     - 3:32 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                    $300 to $500

                    My holiday gift budget will suffer a big cut this year. I feel terrible about it but recession has hit us hard.

                    {"commentId":10451663,"threadId":"715314","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"TheSituation"}
                    • 3 votes
                     - 3:32 pm EST on Tue Nov 3, 2009
                    advertisement

                    Newsvine Discussion with 45 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

                    Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                    {"commentId":10441816,"authorDomain":"henryleslie"}

                    My brother and his wife have for years done the "from the both of us" thing at christmas while as a single person I still felt obligated to get them individual gifts even though I make half as much as they each do. But no more, tired of the expense and tired of being underappreciated. They are getting a "couple gift" from me and the same goes for my dad (regarding restricting expense). I am sick of buying expensive gifts for people that go into their closet. I would rather they return or exchange it. Found last year's gift to sister in law in her bedroom while babysitting nephew (he likes to sleep in mommy's bed." This was 6 months after christmas. My gift meant so little she didn't bother to exchange or return it. I am tired of trying to buy the love of my cold, distant dad and self-absorbed brothers. I am spending a third of what I usally do. I am giving gift cards so folks can get what they want and I am doing more re-gifting too. I am doing whatever it takes. Spending money on expensive gifts that I cant afford and that are rarely appreciated is no way to live and Im done with doing it.

                    {"commentId":10441816,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"henryleslie"}
                    • 5 votes
                    Reply#1 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 7:54 AM EST
                    {"commentId":10451913,"authorDomain":"TheSituation"}

                    I know what you mean about feeling unappreciated. I don't have a lot of money and everyone knows it yet some recipients still see fit to turn their nose up at their gifts. You'd think they'd have the decency to at least pretend to be grateful.

                    {"commentId":10451913,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"TheSituation"}
                    • 1 vote
                    #1.1 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:41 PM EST
                    {"commentId":10453246,"authorDomain":"lemonverbeena"}

                    Sounds like you need a Christmas gift-giving overhaul! Maybe try giving to St. Jude's in their names... no exchange needed!

                    {"commentId":10453246,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lemonverbeena"}
                    • 2 votes
                    #1.2 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 4:32 PM EST
                    {"commentId":10458205,"authorDomain":"gregziglar"}

                    Leslie, I know what you mean. I used to buy gifts for my brother and all his family members (and they all gave me one gift) and the same situation occured with my sister and all her family members.

                    Holiday gifts is all about giving, I understand that. But the truth is, I just can't afford to do that anymore!

                    So, for the past 4 years, and this will be the third, I have bought no one any gifts. (My brother and sister and their families don't speak to me anymore cause they don't get Christmas gifts and Bday gifts, and they think I'm a really bad Christian and have told me so, and they feel they are very good Christians and they've told me that they know I am jealous because they are such good Christians! So, I'm the bad guy in the picture.

                    What, exactly, is a "Good Christian" anyway? Assuming a perfect Christian would be without sin, I'd think a "Good Christian" would be, perhaps, batting 75% on The 10 Commandments? A regular Christian would be at 50%, and I guess a bad Christian would be at 25% or less.

                    I just wish someone would explain this rating system to me.

                    {"commentId":10458205,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"gregziglar"}
                      #1.3 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 8:25 PM EST
                      {"commentId":10460158,"authorDomain":"lxm"}

                      Greg,

                      Remember the Lord said to throw off worldly posssessions and to follow Him. Being a good Christian has nothing to do with gift giving and your family should know better. I think being a good Christian is your relationship with God and being with Him each and every day. Somedays you do good and somedays not so good - the important thing is that everyday you try and do good for God - He knows it and loves you for it.

                      Have a Merry Christmas this year Greg.

                      {"commentId":10460158,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lxm"}
                        #1.4 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 10:16 PM EST
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":10443177,"authorDomain":"cbuckus"}

                        My husband and I will buy our three single children, the youngest is 17, the oldest 28, one to two gifts. My married daughter and her husband, a resturaunt gift card. I will buy a few gifts for my granddaughter that I know she'll really play with, not because she see's them on t.v. I'll buy a gift card for my mother because I know she appreciates them. My siblings and I decided not to exchange gifts this year. My kids will exchange small gifts with their cousins because they spend the day together at my mother's house. In my family we feel that Christmas is a time to reflect on faith and hope, and we also have more fun getting together. My husband and I have his family over our house on Christmas Eve, and on Christmas we spend the day with my family at my mother's house.

                        {"commentId":10443177,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"cbuckus"}
                        • 1 vote
                        Reply#2 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 9:31 AM EST
                        {"commentId":10443802,"authorDomain":"azladywolf"}

                        I'm widowed, but my partner and I never exchanged gifts - for any occasion. We bought when we wanted to show our appreciation for each other. My son was killed 2 years ago, and I have no other children, and no grandchildren. I will give cash to my best friend's two sons, so they can purchase what their young hearts desire (money has always been tight in their family), and I will get something for my boss (as always) who has been so generous to me these past 25 years. I will get something for my Dad, who is 87. My brother's family and I stopped exchanging after their children were grown. For me, life is simple.

                        {"commentId":10443802,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"azladywolf"}
                        • 5 votes
                        Reply#3 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 10:01 AM EST
                        {"commentId":10451175,"authorDomain":"lammie"}

                        AZ LadyWolf--

                        Sounds like YOU got it right!!

                        {"commentId":10451175,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lammie"}
                        • 1 vote
                        #3.1 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:14 PM EST
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":10445382,"authorDomain":"jujubug00"}

                        My husband and I will buy a "store" gift only for our grandson, 9, and our neices, 11 & 1. The people over 18 draw names, so we'll each have one person to get something for. We plan on making/prepping food items to give - we'll be trying out some recipes for great comfort foods like mac-n-cheese, garlic/bacon mashed potatoes - and giving these with a couple of nicely marinated steaks. Sounds a little weird, I know, but people do enjoy getting food so they don't have "regular" cooking to do at Christmastime. And we will enjoy doing it more than just buying and wrapping something.

                        {"commentId":10445382,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"jujubug00"}
                        • 2 votes
                        Reply#4 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 11:18 AM EST
                        {"commentId":10446138,"authorDomain":"tioturtle"}

                        Humbug for the holidays. Any money spent will be cash. The unfairness of banks to raise interest rates on cards but unwillingness to increase our interest on savings and CD's shows their greed. Congress will do nothing about it but laugh since each member is probably individually wealthy.

                        {"commentId":10446138,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"tioturtle"}
                        • 5 votes
                        Reply#5 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 11:54 AM EST
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":10448288,"authorDomain":"kerrydaniel"}

                        I am tired of greed and expectation. For years I bought into the crass commercialism of Christmas. This year will be the second in a row where I spend NOTHING on gifts. My gift to my family this holiday season is a gift of love -- my presence. I long for a time when togetherness was the absolute core of "the holiday spirt." I'm going to do my part to do that. I'm also cutting my card list wayyyyyyy down, sending cards only to those who not only send cards to me, but who also write more than just their name. It's time to stop the madness!

                        {"commentId":10448288,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"kerrydaniel"}
                        • 3 votes
                        Reply#6 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 1:24 PM EST
                        {"commentId":10458311,"authorDomain":"gregziglar"}

                        Kerry, me too. I am buying no gifts, but am visiting family and friends and we will have some good times for free and celebrate the true meaning of Christmas.

                        I don't send cards anymore except to my parents. I used to personalize each card with a handwritten note inside, but I get so tired of these "form" cards that aren't personalized at all except for my address on the outside. That tells me that the sender could care less about delivering a sincere Christmas/Holiday wish directed to me, personally.

                        {"commentId":10458311,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"gregziglar"}
                          #6.1 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 8:29 PM EST
                          Reply
                          {"commentId":10449189,"authorDomain":"Hpanalyst"}

                          My wife and I stopped buying expensive gifts years ago. Last year we purchased all of our gifts at the apple orchard and winery in our town. Simple things like a gift basket with local wine and cheese, pots of jam or a handmade wooden toy. All were appreciated, helped my local economy and was a throwback to a simpler time for Christmas.

                          {"commentId":10449189,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"Hpanalyst"}
                          • 5 votes
                          Reply#7 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 1:58 PM EST
                          {"commentId":10449877,"authorDomain":"timto"}

                          Small turkey and cash only Christmas, and it's going to feel great. This dip in the economy has taught me some wonderful lessons.

                          I hope the banks, the news media, our government and credit card companies heed Abraham Lincoln's message "You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time. Best wishes to all, Scrooge.

                          {"commentId":10449877,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"timto"}
                          • 4 votes
                          Reply#8 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 2:25 PM EST
                          {"commentId":10450145,"authorDomain":"brian-porter-1"}

                          I am not going into debt for the first time in years. I will spend a reasonable amount on kids and grandkids and call it a day. I will get out the day after Black Friday and haggle with the retailers and still get what I want at sale price.

                          God Bless You & Keep You

                          He's The Real Reason For The Season

                          {"commentId":10450145,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"brian-porter-1"}
                          • 5 votes
                          Reply#9 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 2:35 PM EST
                          Reply
                          {"commentId":10450969,"authorDomain":"1happycamper"}

                          I do gifts for my children and husband, he gets one for me, and everyone else I bake care packages for, we don't go all out just simple things, extravagent spending isn't what christmas is all about. we never spend more than 300 dollars in gifts all together. I like to get the kids a bunch of little items so they have more to open. At 4 and 2 one and a half year olds, they are pretty easy to please right now.

                          {"commentId":10450969,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"1happycamper"}
                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#10 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:07 PM EST
                          {"commentId":10451002,"authorDomain":"junep4"}

                          I have 5 children and a few of them are still young so I'll spend more than I want to so they can have some new toys as well as needs. Other than my children, I buy a few necessities for my husband and something small for my parents. Friends and other family members get nothing more than a sincere "Merry Christmas!".

                          {"commentId":10451002,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"junep4"}
                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#11 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:08 PM EST
                          {"commentId":10451110,"authorDomain":"playbeezy"}

                          We donate our money to a few different charities in the names of our loved ones instead of sending it up to a corporate vampire. The money stays local, those who need it most are helped instead, and everyone learns the true meaning of giving and receiving.

                          {"commentId":10451110,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"playbeezy"}
                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#12 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:12 PM EST
                          {"commentId":10451141,"authorDomain":"dorrianvance"}

                          My main concern this year is my 4 children.  They will defintely be getting less this year then in previous years.  I work in an industry that we are barely scraping by and I don't know how much longer I'll have my job.

                          I've also looked at some of the black friday ads that have already been posted and I haven't seen anything that I thought was a great deal.  The article is right, the things people need/want they aren't lowering the prices on.

                          {"commentId":10451141,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"dorrianvance"}
                            Reply#13 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:13 PM EST
                            {"commentId":10451215,"authorDomain":"ken-1449643"}

                            This economy is the worst I have ever seen. I worry a lot about the job situation for my kids. I am sure we will all do with a lot less this year. May we all remember the reason for the season.

                            {"commentId":10451215,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"ken-1449643"}
                              Reply#14 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:16 PM EST
                              {"commentId":10451227,"authorDomain":"lammie"}

                              I have been "giving" gifts from Heifer International for folks. Helping the needy around the world help themselves suits me.

                              I also give to local charities and local animal shelters. I don't want/need anything. Help others.

                              {"commentId":10451227,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"lammie"}
                              • 1 vote
                              Reply#15 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:17 PM EST
                              Reply
                              {"commentId":10451613,"authorDomain":"dawnjspath"}

                              I am probably going to get board games for my siblings. I think last year they got nice new socks like some name brand wool socks. Useful in Montana and not unappreciated. And for my folks they might just get a new Christmas ornament because this year we actually get to spend Christmas together which is gift enough for myself. As for my husband and I; I would like to put a cap on it. Last year we went all out but this year we're expecting and I would rather get stuff for our baby than for each other. I don't know about his family though; that's always hard.

                              {"commentId":10451613,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"dawnjspath"}
                                Reply#16 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:31 PM EST
                                {"commentId":10451691,"authorDomain":"science--1"}

                                My gift to each family this year will be home baked cookies in $1 baskets (from the dollar store.) I will save $400 over last year; spending far less now than on any Christmas of the last twenty. Ho-Ho-oh..

                                {"commentId":10451691,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"science--1"}
                                • 2 votes
                                Reply#17 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:33 PM EST
                                {"commentId":10451740,"authorDomain":"readermystery43"}

                                Practical gifts only this year. Paying my mother's property taxes on her house will be her gift. Tough year financially for her.

                                {"commentId":10451740,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"readermystery43"}
                                • 2 votes
                                Reply#18 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:35 PM EST
                                {"commentId":10451793,"authorDomain":"TheSituation"}

                                Our holiday spending will take a huge cut this year. I feel terrible about it but the recession has hit us hard. The kids and my husband will still get storebought gifts from me but less will be spent on them this year. His parents and my parents and other immediate family members will get mostly crafts and baked goods, with only one or two inexpensive store bought gifts. And friends, unfortunately, will get only a card. Everyone will be disappointed but when things get better hopefully I can make up for it.

                                {"commentId":10451793,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"TheSituation"}
                                  Reply#19 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:36 PM EST
                                  {"commentId":10457388,"authorDomain":"dianeid"}

                                  If they love you, you shouldn't have to make it up to them later. The holidays are for sharing love and time with the ones you love, not buying them things. Good luck and Happy Holidays!

                                  {"commentId":10457388,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"dianeid"}
                                  • 2 votes
                                  #19.1 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 7:41 PM EST
                                  Reply
                                  {"commentId":10452075,"authorDomain":"bethwashere"}

                                  This year I lost my house, why would I buy hundreds in gifts if I can't even keep a roof over my head...

                                  Thank you worthless degree.

                                  {"commentId":10452075,"threadId":"715443","contentId":"3452985","authorDomain":"bethwashere"}
                                    Reply#20 - Tue Nov 3, 2009 3:47 PM EST
                                    Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                    {"canLink":false,"threadId":"715443","isPrivate":false}
                                    Leave a Comment:
                                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.